About

My Photo

Become a Fan

« How the wheel turns: from 9/11 to 22/7 | Main | The empty threat from Irene »

August 03, 2011

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451cbbc69e2014e8a5ae1c5970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Can we have the silly season back, please?:

Comments

The trouble with your posts is that they send my thoughts ricocheting round Wikipedia, and 2 weeks later (or is it longer?) I still haven't assembled something coherent enough to be called a "comment". So in lieu of a constructive response, or a silly Private Eye cover, here's a blog of me reading your blog... (It's a one time thing, I promise.)

It was the Hermetic axiom which fired me off. I've known about it since I was a teenager (thanks, Mary Gentle); but it wasn't until you made me think about it again, that I realised the Hermeticists were talking about symmetry.

[[To a mathematician, symmetry is a "generalisation" of "mirroring", and describes any situation where something looks the same, despite a change taking place. So, for example, a shape that looks like its reflection has "mirror" symmetry. Or if a plot of the tone of each year's new stories looks identical--with the same frothy patch in August--then the news has a "Calendar symmetry" (well, a translation symmetry along the temporal axis).]]

Linking symmetry with the Hermeticists made me realise that lead spontaneously transforms into gold (well, some radioisotopes decay into mercury, which then decay into gold, which then decays in seconds into something else...). I'd never stopped to think about that before. I guess it's down to the SU(2) flavour symmetry of the weak nuclear force. But the alchemists were right: symmetry turns lead into gold. And that left me pondering how a universe which is itself deeply, deeply symmetric has led to sentient life which is also fine-tuned to spot symmetry. And so my thoughts tumbled on into metaphysics... (Could God be a symmetry?)

But anyway, it was a beautiful post. Like a little poem. (It even had me nodding along saying, "No, I'm not a mystic, either" - as if that was a completely and totally reasonable thing to contemplate.) But I have to disagree (a little) - I can't help thinking the world would be a much better place if the silly season went on all year round. ;)

a_spod: Amazing! Did this short post of mine really spur such a long train of thought?

I'm flattered.

Though I have to admit that I had forgotten that that saying was called the Hermetic axiom. As you, I learned about it as a teenager, it fascinated me immensly then - albeit as an abstract idea.

But for the last few years I've found myself thinking about it often, although foremostly while contemplating how microcosmos mirrors macrocosmos and vice versa.

And even then, the main reason this thought keeps hunting me is because I used to think I needed a Phd in just about everything that interested me in order to really understand the world (philosophy, physics, finance, psychology etc etc).

As I've grown wiser about the world and gotten to learn various industries from the inside, I've come to see that notion as a rather silly idea. I've more and more come to see that people are driven by the same things regardless of their vocation and position in the world - and as a result, what drives say politics and finance are fundamentally much the same.

In a really cynical mood I might even argue that a lot of the things that ail the world come down to people going to all sorts of bisarre lengths to avoid making difficult decisisons.

That's of course no reason not to study natural sciences, but certainly for not doing Phds in human and political sciences;-)

I wonder, if the silly season just went on and on, would't people just invent strife, conflict and a reason to bring back more dramatic headlines?

Also, there may be some explanation for that instinct for drama in Western culture as Western and Asian litterature is very different in this respect .. but on that note I better call it a night. My mind is much too tired for investigating that train of thought right now;-)

Yeah, essentially, that train of thought departed from your blog. My thoughts aren't composed entirely of words. And I don't tend to have short trains of thought. But you released the break. And that's why I come here. :)

And you've repaid me again with the insight that society is driven by "procrastination". It's not the whole story. But it's a useful model that I will deploy time and time again. (I have to say, though, that I still envy anyone who knows more than me. I WANNA KNOW IT ALL!)

Anyway, don't interpret silence (from me) as a lack of interest: so often I don't have time to wrestle an idea into words. Or, just as I sit down to do so, you publish another blog that's easier to comment on. (And I do like to comment on *other* people's blogs, too. ;-) Definitely, don't let your subconscious trick you into seeing a pattern in my comments, because there isn't one; I could say something about most of your posts, and when and where my comments appear is driven by my workload and other commitments.

You're right about the final point, though: people would invent strife. We even have a name for the pseudo-drama they invent: THE SILLY SEASON. "ZOMG! Have you seen the price of prawns?!!!!" :-P :-P :-P

(My point: there is a partial order on news stories, with those that involve people dying being bottom of the heap. I know nothing about Asian culture, so you're on your own there; but it would be interesting, if true.)

Thanks, a_spod - I appereciate that my ramblings here can have such an effect. See what makes me tick is intellectual mid-wifery – if what I write or do can spark new ideas, interesting debates or new, better and/ or more informed ways of doing or seeing things (and I do love being part of debates and conversations that can do that too). So thanks for the compliment:-) Sorry about my late reply - the wknd you wrote this was busy due to a friend being ill and me looking after her, then I've been ill etc. But this week my mind's finally starting to work properly again;-)

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.